US Is Underpricing “Investor Green Cards”

According to an article-The American Dream Of The Chinese Rich-in today’s China Daily:

the number of so-called “investor green cards” issued to non-Americans nearly tripled to 4,218 in the 2009 fiscal year. About 1,800 of those recipients are from the Chinese mainland. South Korea is second with 903 recipients.

The minimum required for an “investor green card” used to be $1 million. Now it is $500,000. Leave it to the genius economists of the US government to cut the price in the face of both inflation and increasing demand.

$500,000 is pocket change for a large number of newly rich Chinese. As the article states:

Most of the investors are quite wealthy and $500,000 represents only a small portion of their wealth. Liu Jie, for example, said she would sell a few apartments to pay for her part of the investment immigration program.

In a time of huge budget deficits and rising taxes, why doesn’t the US government consider a market pricing mechanism for these “investor green cards”? An auction system might work, and the government could set the reserve price at $5 Million and probably see no decrease in demand or job creation.

UPDATE: Today’s New York Times also has an article on the boom in selling immigration to Chinese, not just to the United States but also Canada, Australia, Hong Kong, Singapore and New Zealand. The Canadians are ahead of the US when it comes to raising the price. Canada (excluding Quebec)

temporarily halted its program in June in order to double the amount that would-be immigrants must invest to qualify. Whereas before applicants required a net worth of 800,000 Canadian dollars, or about $790,000, and a 400,000-dollar investment, in the future they will need 1.6 million dollars and an investment of 800,000 dollars.

Please tell me what you think in the comments.

If you use RSS you can subscribe to this blog’s feed here, and if you use Twitter you can follow my more frequent updates @niubi, and if you use Sina Weibo you can follow me here. You can also follow my blogging on digital media and the Internet in China at DigiCha.

Subscribe to the Free Sinocism China Newsletter! Enter Your Email In The Box Below And Start Getting Smarter About China.

10 thoughts on “US Is Underpricing “Investor Green Cards”

  1. Good analysis and terrific suggestion that would have no problem sailing through Congress (so long as nobody viewed it as a tax). Just forwarded this to some friends on the hill.

  2. Good analysis and terrific suggestion that would have no problem sailing through Congress (so long as nobody viewed it as a tax). Just forwarded this to some friends on the hill.

  3. could it be that they’re treating the card as a loss leader? get the guys that can afford it over and they’ll bring a lot more than what they paid/invested.

  4. could it be that they're treating the card as a loss leader? get the guys that can afford it over and they'll bring a lot more than what they paid/invested.

    • I guess we have to figure out what are “legitimate” entrepreneurs. One
      of the people featured in the China Daily article is a “Hebei mine
      owner”; I really don’t think that is the kind of entrepreneur most
      Americans have in mind.

      This program is very different than the startup visa one that we may
      soon get; that will attract entrepreneurs.

  5. I guess we have to figure out what are “legitimate” entrepreneurs. One
    of the people featured in the China Daily article is a “Hebei mine
    owner”; I really don't think that is the kind of entrepreneur most
    Americans have in mind.

    This program is very different than the startup visa one that we may
    soon get; that will attract entrepreneurs.

Comments are closed.