265 Comments
User's avatar
Steve Carroll's avatar

I started Chinese language at college in 1972. I got my BA in Chinese, and then worked in Taiwan for 10 years and China 15 years. Fortunately when I went to Taiwan in 1973-1977, China was closed due to the Cultural Revolution, so I spent my first decade plus in Taiwan, a really great country. My Chinese was also extremely useful in Burma, Thailand, Pakistan and Greece. I encourage all young students to start early.

Expand full comment
pfuhlir's avatar

I have to say, this has been an excellent read since your readers are well-informed and the questions--and answers--incisive

Expand full comment
Raul Picaporte's avatar

do you think it would be useful, in the context of a trade war that may not end in the forseeable future -and one that may have perhaps at least part of its root dug in a deep cultural misunderstanding- for Western countries to start learning Chinese, like China is learning English?

Expand full comment
Johnny b's avatar

Just saw this. Is it finished ?

Expand full comment
Honey's avatar

Got to this a little late, but thoroughly enjoyed reading the thread. Great idea.

Expand full comment
Steve Carroll's avatar

Excellent exchange of ideas. Trump has forced China’s hand, everything is clearer now. China is preparing to go without the USA. Focus on ROW.

Expand full comment
Greg's avatar

Great idea, a little more advance notice probably works better, at least for me.

Expand full comment
Janet oesterly's avatar

How is the US/China trade war affecting the Belt and Road project? Is there more interest in Europe for the Road ?

Expand full comment
Karl Weaver's avatar

By the way Samsung, HTC, Sirin Labs (Israel) and Pundi X (Singapore) all have Blockchain Smartphones on the market and crypto currency usage with crypto wallets is not dying it is growing so why have all the Chinese Smartphone vendors not realized that since they sell their Smartphones globally, not just in China that they are causing their subscribers a huge risk by not using exiting security technology already in the Smartphones to protect private keys stored on the phone?

Expand full comment
Karl Weaver's avatar

Hello Bill, Why have all the Mainland Chinese Smartphone manufacturers not developed a Blockchain Smartphone, that is a Smartphone which either has its own crypto currency wallet enabled or the ability to protect other downloaded crypto currency wallets globally from Android Play Store, as there are literally hundreds being downloaded now onto Smartphones globally (outside of China) and none of wallets are protected in tamper resistant hardware on the phone and all use Android os. This is a huge security risk for the theft of the private keys in the wallets of Android os Smartphones to be stolen, and Chinese Smartphone vendors know this but it seems because their own Government bans the use of Crypto wallets inside the country they don't feel they need to worry about hackers routing their consumers' Smartphones globally to steal crypto currencies. What is the story with all this? Thanks,

Expand full comment
H2o4me2's avatar

Do we precisely know what the US is requiring of China???

Expand full comment
oneonder's avatar

(1) end technology transfers, (2) fair treatment for foreign companies, (3) reduce industrial subsidies, (4) end China's economic espionage against non-Chinese companies, (5) reduce non-tariff barriers, including those used to punish foreign countries for disobeying China.

Expand full comment
k0zy's avatar

gah, think i just missed it but wondering if there were any whispers on which companies might be on this rumored blacklist? Like this idea, Bill!

Expand full comment
chris's avatar

i like this idea!

Expand full comment
C. Lange's avatar

I am late to the party. So glad that you will be doing this again. Thank you so much Beale for your expertise and more than that, sharing it with us.

Expand full comment
Rami's avatar

Two questions: what are the cards-besides rare-earths and the US companies working in China- China holds in the current conflict?

Second question: do you think there will be European contries, besides Italy hat will sign silk-road related agreements? Thank Bill

Expand full comment
amalist's avatar

Bill, your thoughts on Xi planning a Second Informal face-to-face with Indian Prime Minister N Modi in India, in light of their first one in which Xi had personally taken Modi to his home province...?

Expand full comment
Felix's avatar

Good idea. Will comment in the future.

Expand full comment
Will's avatar

Should the US have a policy of reciprocity with China with regards to educations and media? Do you think the US will do anything meaningful to combat ccp influence in schools and Hollywood?

Expand full comment
Dan's avatar

Hi Bill. Do you think attacks against Huawei are felt more personally by China than trade tariffs or ZTE sanctions? (Which had more legitimate judicial backing because of Iran sanction violations.) I've heard some commentary that because Huawei is a national treasure of China, a truly innovative company, that it feels like a more personal and unfair attack, which plays into the whole "contain China" narrative and is contributing to a surge in nationalistic sentiment.

Expand full comment
Bill Bishop's avatar

Thanks everyone, will do this again soon. have a good weekend

Expand full comment
Nora's avatar

You too, Bill.

Expand full comment
Matt Geraci's avatar

Thanks, Bill!

Expand full comment
Jing's avatar

Thank you, Bill.

Expand full comment
Dan's avatar

Thanks, Bill!

Expand full comment
Andrew L's avatar

Hi Bill, long time subscriber here, keep up the good work. Wondering if you could share some insight into your reader base? What's the split between investors, corporate, entrepreneurs, analysts, politicians, academics and any other group?

Expand full comment
polnick's avatar

Higher Chinese IQ will outfox low IQ West. East wind blows more intelligence.

Expand full comment
Luke's avatar

Do you think it is our intention to decouple the tech and trade from China? If so, what’s the benefit?

Expand full comment
Kevin Russell's avatar

As China electric transporation sector zooms past all, do they have a 'gas tax' per gallon, which goes to road maintenance like in the US? Backwards states like NC, have proposed legislation to increase registration on electric and hybrid vehicles, missing the clear air public health, habitat, biodiversity 'value' benefits.

Expand full comment
Yang Yu's avatar

One thing that has always baffled me...what's the end game with this trade war? Is it to force China to open more? Or is it to force America companies to extract China from their supply chain? The latter seems hard to imagine a few weeks ago, but it seems like it is becoming a reality?

Expand full comment
Adam B. Lee's avatar

Thanks for doing this, Bill. What factors - or possible warning signs - led you to return to Washington from Beijing?

Expand full comment
Bill Bishop's avatar

i talked about them in this 2015 podcast http://www.chinafile.com/library/sinica-podcast/china-watchers-china-watcher-decamps?fbclid=IwAR0YNa3ejj4jv88p1ib9Yn-cgYUpGF48fVcAYaECKLY2s2HoJQOefnpFIeI

"While not exactly your requisite “Why I Am Leaving China” blog post, this show gives Kaiser Kuo and David Moser the chance to talk to Bill about the reasons behind his decision, and explore why he sees an increasingly strained relationship between China and the United States over the next few years."

Expand full comment
Bill Bishop's avatar

Thanks everyone, sorry if I did not get to your question, and apologies for the initial tech issues. One thing I did not see mentioned is Taiwan. I think Taiwan is going to become an even friction point in the near future, between the upcoming elections, and the fact that Tsai has a challenger inside the DPP, as well as possible US moves.

Expand full comment
EC's avatar

if you get the chance: what do you think about the near- and long-term future of Taiwan as a nation-state and/or as a Chinese province (or something in between)? Will America be able to guard the status quo? Would Taiwanese necessarily even want American support for the status quo when presented with continuing inducements from Beijing? What is the likelihood of a Chinese invasion? Since the CCP would almost certainly fight to the death for Taiwan, is the Trump administration (and future administrations) prepared for an endless war to defend Taiwan?

Expand full comment
Rob's avatar

Just an FYI this thread spammed my email address after replying to it

Expand full comment
Tashi's avatar

Sorry we are going to fix that

Expand full comment
Bryan Alexander's avatar

Very good thing to do, Bill.

Expand full comment
Filippo S.'s avatar

Hi Bill, we're one and a half year into Trump's maximum pressure campaign against China, how much do you think it has weakend Xi, if it has? Thanks

Expand full comment
Bill Bishop's avatar

i think it has strengthened xi. given everything trump is doing globally it is really hard to make a cogent argument that xi screwed up the trade talks, unless you think he should have just rolled over. in fact, xi can say this guy is impossible to deal with and he has shown us clearly what many of us believed anyway, that us is out to keep us down, and so the only way to push back on the us it be more unified and unified around a strong leader with a strong military

Expand full comment
Filippo S.'s avatar

yes, that's a great point. But I also hear that managing the relationship with the us is one of the key deliverables xi is judged on, and some say that he has unnecessairly overexposed china. one might argue that being less aggressive on some issues (South China Sea, B&R), china wouldn't be facing the kind of bypartisan antagonism it is now facing in the us

Expand full comment
JoRo's avatar

What do you think the greatest challenges are in EU-China trade today?

Expand full comment
Brian's avatar

Bill, what percent of the people you interact with on China would you estimate actually understand that China's banking system is a fractional reserve system as exists in the West, ie the banks are literally creating money each time they make loans? And all public disclosure of any non-performing loans have to be pre-approved by the Party -- down to the individual loan level?

Expand full comment
JoRo's avatar

What do you think the biggest challenge is in Europe-China trade relations today?

Expand full comment
Filippo S.'s avatar

Hi Bill, we're one and a half year into this maximum pressure campaign by the US, how much do you think it has weakened Xi Jinping, if it has?

Expand full comment
Bill Bishop's avatar

Bill, what percent of the people you interact with on China would you estimate actually understand that China's banking system is a fractional reserve system as exists in the West, ie the banks are literally creating money each time they make loans? And all public disclosure of any non-performing loans have to be pre-approved by the Party -- down to the individual loan level?

Expand full comment
Luke's avatar

How far do you think the White House would go in this trade war? It looks it is always we strikes first and they fight back.

Expand full comment
Benjamen DoVale's avatar

When will you go on Joe Rogan podcast?

Expand full comment
Chris Best's avatar

+1!!

Expand full comment
Jaim LONGHI's avatar

Will the Chinese continue to import oil from Iran, and in doing so, what is the cost to them for thumbing their noses at US dictum?

Expand full comment
Bodhivata Dharmashanti's avatar

With all the illegal practices China hasbbeen involced wouldn't mske sense to request the UN to setup an investigative committe with powers of slapping sanctions and heavy monetary "tickets" if not even prosecute them legally. Someone has to make them accountable or they will continue yo operate thinking they are above the law. Dont forget there are billoons of them!

Thank you for your reply.

Bodhi from Brooklyn NY

Expand full comment
Carl Riedy's avatar

How do you think the Chinese leadership is assessing the 2020 elections and the impact of various outcomes?

Expand full comment
Jing's avatar

There were moments of spiking nationalist sentiment in the past, such as 1999 (embassy bombing), 2001 (Hainan crash) and 2012 (Senkaku/Diaoyu). How do you compare what's going on now to those moments?

Expand full comment
Bill Bishop's avatar

i think we are creeping up towards those levels, and the propaganda shift in the last several weeks is a sign of that.

Expand full comment
Matthew Cheresh's avatar

Rare earths are incredibly intertwined with at least all electronics manufacturing. It is difficult for China to cut off the west, but they could leverage their rare earth position to capture a greater share of the value chain. Does Trump have amyone who understands this?

Expand full comment
Bill Bishop's avatar

i believe people in the pentagon do, and they have been aware of this issue fir a while. awareness though may not have led to good enough preparation

Expand full comment
Matthew Cheresh's avatar

Makes sense they would. No rare earths, no F-16s, no Humvees, or even the machine tools to make them. No rare earths, no modern electric motors.

Expand full comment
Matthew Cheresh's avatar

Thank you, this is great!

Expand full comment
Luke's avatar

Do you see the tension with China is a conflict of civilization?

Expand full comment
Bill Bishop's avatar

i think china see the conflict with the us as one

Expand full comment
Luke's avatar

How about us? Do you think most people here see it this way?

Expand full comment
Abhishek's avatar

Thoughts on the recent Chinese rebuff in Sri Lanka's Colombo port?

Expand full comment
Chris Best's avatar

Sorry about this. Hit the “mute this thread” button in the email and they’ll stop

Expand full comment
Jing Zhang's avatar

Bill, can you disable sending email to users for each comment?

Expand full comment
Bill Bishop's avatar

i will ask, that is annoying. sorry

Expand full comment
Jing's avatar

There have been moments of spiking nationalist sentiment in the past, such as 1999 (embassy bombing), 2001 (Hainan crash), and 2012 (Senkaku/Diaoyu). How do you compare what we are seeing now to those moments?

Expand full comment
Jojje's avatar

What do you think will be the most obvious and the most effective way(s) in which China will be trying to affect the outcome in the coming Taiwan presidential elections?

Expand full comment
Jaim LONGHI's avatar

Will the Chinese continue to import oil from Iran? And if so, is this not a very clear crossing of a "red line?"

Expand full comment
Robert's avatar

What is the likelihood or the possibility of this trade war triggering an actual physical confrontation. We saw that Kennedy and Kruschev almost lost control of their own military during the Cuban missile crisis. At one point they both felt like they were losing control of the situation.

Expand full comment
Matt Geraci's avatar

I'm sure you've got quite a lot of questions to respond to here, so I just wanted to thank you for taking the time to hold this kind of forum. I hope this weekly thread becomes a regular Friday ritual for me to read through and and post in.

Expand full comment
98KY's avatar

How can we help curb the utter ignorance and animosity of people in the U.S. towards China (including the Washington DC elite)?

Expand full comment
AlternativeData's avatar

Is this trade war real in terms of the long term social and political impact on China? Isn't it in the party's long term legitimacy to get any deal with the U.S. than a no deal on trade?

Expand full comment